Why do people hate lotr

The only weakness here is in satisfying character motivation. But character arcs flatline throughout because logic and motivation are treated in the same manner as the many set-pieces, contrivances to suit a Byzantine plot that takes hours to run in place. But the myth itself is long and repetitive.

In between, they do find Gollum, a CGI-character ironically infused with more soul than the live actors. Legolas, Gimli and Aragorn, meanwhile, kill Orcs at an ever faster rate. In the nadir of the series, Merry and Pippin, the Cheech and Chong of Middle Earth, hug a walking, verse-spouting tree in one of the most clock-stopping sequences put to film. How would you like this article to have ended three paragraphs ago? Each movie should offer at least a taste of closure, rather than be content with itself as a single frustrated act of an epic designed to suck 30 bucks from my billfold.

And how I wish I could like it. He had a good point. The other half of the book is filled with these long and grueling elf chants. So what if their walking over mountains? Just the fact that anyone could come up with this highly detailed boring, repetitive, confusing story is something that deserves 2 stars. Aside from that, the structure of [ The Two Towers] is all whacked. The first half is spent entirely with Aragorn and his crew.

Is this considered good, when your main character is not even present for the majority of the book? Too often all that happens is they travel, eat, and sleep. There was singing, also. The characters are just as bland as the dialogue. There is no or little character development in this book, despite its size. Man, that is fruity!

Share this: Twitter Facebook. Like this: Like Loading Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:. Email required Address never made public. This time, about two-thirds of the way through and with the help of a between-scenes text convo with a dear friend , something clicked into place.

But what you fear most , depends on who you are. Some people fear being alone. Some people fear failure, or their own incompetence. Some people fear control or domination.

I fear becoming evil. More specifically—being made evil against my will. I fear being turned into a monster. Take your pick. Evil desire. Yes, Professor Tolkien. You took my Absolute Worst Fear. There is no escape from its clutches. No one is safe. No matter how good, how strong, how kind, how pure— everyone falls in the end. He yields to it. It was by sheer chance that the Ring was finally destroyed, instead of Frodo keeping it forever, a slave to its withering cruelty.

Corruption spreads its tentacles through this entire universe. For me. When I feel like the darkness is taking over. In my own life, I believe in the Light. I believe in goodness. And most days , I believe in the promise of my own salvation. Because Tolkien, the man, the artist, the Christian, would never want any of his readers to feel that way.

I know people have a ton of feelings on this subject, so. These events occur later on in the story. But that said, I think I can understand. And I think you will, too. Thank you for being so open minded and understanding to us who are rather attached to this particular story. Like Like. Also, another point made that I forgot to mention :P is this: I was at a party once, and got in an animated conversation with a stranger about Lord of the Rings, and he asked me this one question that made me re-think a lot of the story: Who is the hero of Lord of the Rings?

But his point was solid — Sam. Even though he seems like the side-character, Sam is actually the hero of the story.

Spoilers: It is he who carries the ring and does not succumb to it, but uses it purely for good — being the only one to have done expressly that.

Like Liked by 2 people. Oh no!!! I would never trash the series or criticize all the lovely people who enjoy it. Just because it messes with MY mental health doesn't make it "bad.

Sam is the true hero, huh? Though the world is plunged in darkness for much of the story, the light wins in the end. I find it fascinating that neither of you want to watch movies that deal with your core fears. If anything, I think that would make me MORE likely to watch something — to explore it on an intellectual level, safe from my couch!

Vertigo has a really sick, twisted ending, after a sick, twisted plot-line. Like Liked by 1 person. Yeah, to be honest, I dislike Vertigo more for the twistedness and hopelessness than for the scene where she supposedly falls off the tower.

Elrond could have taken it from Frodo when he healed him at Rivendell — he did not. Gandalf could have taken it when Frodo offered it to him in the Shire — he did not. Faramir was tempted, but when Sam told him what happened to his brother — he wisely let Frodo go and told his father of the destruction tied to the Ring.

And Sam carries it for Frodo part of the way, and gives it back to him. But, yes, the ultimate message is that evil does not win, in the end it will be destroyed, that the pure of heart remain faithful to the ways of good and find their greater fulfillment in the end. Frodo does sacrifice his innocence, but he also goes to live in the Gray Havens with the Elves — the Middle-earth version of Heaven. My own experience with the story is thus: I had never seen nor heard of Tolkien until Fellowship came out.

It branched out into a discussion forum, where I met my still best friend. Watching the movies, for me, floods my mind with a ton of rich symbolism and emotional depth … and a handful of nostalgic memories of how I found some of my favorite people in all the world.

And inevitable. And irreversible.